top of page

Reserve-Funding Hysteria is Based on a Falsehood

muskratmusic
11 hours ago
4 min read

Read about the NIST Report, and then Let’s End the Abuse of Community Budgets



The collapse in 2021 of the Champlain Towers South building, a 12-story condo in Surfside, Florida, took the lives of 98 people. In the wake of that shock, many states passed laws requiring HOA and condo associations to beef up their “reserve funds” to cover future maintenance, repair, and replacement of community-owned structures. (1)

 

The Real Cause of the Collapse

A keystone 2026 report by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has quietly debunked the myth that the collapse of the building was the result of neglected maintenance. (2) Meticulous research has found, instead, that the failure had two causes: “severe and wide-spread deviations in the building’s original structural design from the codes and standards of the day… And, second, deviations in the building’s construction [in 1981] from the design drawing.” 

 

Laws Built on a Myth

Let us repeat this finding far and wide: Neglecting maintenance was not a cause of the condo-building collapse in Florida. Most homeowners care very much about the wellbeing of their home and the common property. They do not need to be punished or coerced into taking care of it.

   Maryland, and other states, must now get busy and amend or repeal laws – based on prejudice against homeowners –  that have caused economic distress for homeowners and our communities. (3) The rest of this article details some of that damage to homeowners and communities, and suggests reform.

   While planning and setting money aside for future needs is a duty of good HOA and condo governance (4), legal requirements to do so have gone off the rails. (5) Beginning in 2022, Maryland law requires associations to meet the amounts recommended in “reserve studies,” which are estimates, not perfect predictions, of future expenses. Some homeowners are distressed by monthly assessments that have ballooned as a result of the severe demands suddenly enshrined in such laws, not to mention misinterpretation of laws by HOA and condo boards and property management companies. In short, “reserve funds” can distort community budgets and harm homeowners financially.

 

Profiting from the Panic 

There are profits to be made from this hysteria. By legally mandating recurring, expensive third-party reserve studies and strict funding catch-ups, the state has effectively created a government-enforced revenue stream for a narrow group of private corporate vendors at the direct expense of working-class families and retirees. Forcing a rigid, one-size-fits-all mathematical formula onto associations strips owners of their vote and boards of their authority. It forces massive amounts of capital out of families' pockets to sit in low-yield accounts for projects decades away. In some communities, that can leave little for daily operations and services that affect quality of life in the community now. 

 

A One-Size-Fits-All Trap

A one-size-fits-all law denies the reality that the calculations for setting aside reserve funds for a townhouse HOA (where the only commonly owned property is some lawn) is different from those needed for a two-story garden-unit building – and is very different from those needed for a 12-story high-rise with a pool, parking garage, and tennis court.

   Hyper-aggressive reserve-funding timelines do not reflect the actual economic or material realities of a community. Fixed-income seniors, young families, and working-class Marylanders are being hit with sudden, massive special assessments and skyrocketing monthly fees, triggering a foreclosure and housing affordability crisis. In sum, fixed requirements for reserve-fund contributions are an added threat to affordable housing.

 

Time to Demand Reform

Take a look at the elaborate and reader-friendly webpages that NIST has posted on the important topic of the real causes of the Florida condo collapse in 2021. The “HOA reserve fund hysteria” that has roared across the country like an Oklahoma tornado, with community budgets and homeowners’ financial security under attack, must now come to an end. In Maryland, we must strive to quickly reverse the harm that is being done to HOA and condo homeowners by harmful laws and practices that are based on unfounded fear, not on facts. (6)

 

NOTES This article is available as a 2-sided PDF for printing out at https://www.charm-md.org/resources


(1) ”In recent years, we have seen a notable surge in state legislation focused on reserve requirements and funding, particularly following the 2021 tragic condominium collapse in Surfside, Fla. …”,  CAI Updates Reserve Study and Funding Public Policy, https://advocacy.caionline.org/cai-updates-reserve-study-and-funding-public-policy/; State laws have changed “following the collapse of Champlain Towers South in Surfside, FL in June 2021,” Summary of State Reserve Fund Laws (As of September 2024), www.caionline.org/publications.

(2) https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2026/06/nist-releases-technical-findings-what-caused-2021-partial-collapse  (Includes short and long videos explaining the building’s collapse and the revealing research).

(3) Related Maryland reserve fund laws for condo associations, §11–109.4; and for HOAs, §11B-112.3. Intro to navigating state law; see www.charm-md.org, Resource #4: “Top HOA/Condo Laws Everyone Should Know.”

(4) Operations and safety of high-rise buildings, for example, rely on frameworks like the International Building Code (IBC) https://archive.org/details/gov.law.icc.ibc.2012; NFPA 101 Life Safety Code; and structural specifications such as ASCE/SEI 7-2022 for wind and seismic loads.

(6) We used AI while researching the damage done to individual homeowners and communities in Maryland and building standards such as the IBC.

 

CHARM Maryland, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) civic advocacy organization, incorporated in the state of Maryland, dedicated to fighting for the rights and interests of individual homeowners who live in HOA and condo communities. Current Maryland law is tilted heavily in the interest of boards of directors and their management companies. We're here to change that -- with your help. CHARM stands for Common Ownership Community Homeowners Advocating for ReforM.





 
 

Recent Posts

See All
CHARM MARYLAND QUESTIONS EFFECTIVENESS OF CCOC

Too Many Condo/HOA Homeowner Disputes Are Going Unresolved CHARM Maryland Press Release GAITHERSBURG, MD, September 17, 2026 – In a meeting with Montgomery County Council President Natali Fani-Gonzál

 
 
bottom of page